Login Subscribe
    • Players/Parents
    • College Coaches
  • Choose Your State Middle School Coverage
    Alabama
    Arizona
    Arkansas
    California
    Canada
    Colorado
    Dakotas
    Florida
    Georgia
    Idaho
    Illinois
    Indiana
    Iowa
    Kansas
    Kentucky
    Louisiana
    Maryland
    Michigan
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Missouri
    Nebraska
    Nevada
    New England
    New Jersey
    New Mexico
    New York
    North Carolina
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Oregon
    Pennsylvania
    South Carolina
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Utah
    Virginia
    Washington
    West Virginia
    Wisconsin
  • Loading...
  • Tournaments
    • 7 on 7 7 on 7
    Showcases
    • Combine Series Combine Series
    About Our Events
  • Prep Redzone for
    • Players
    • Parents
    • Club Coaches
    • High School Coaches
    • College Coaches
    • Fans
    View All Features
    • Coverage Access Prep Redzone articles year-round without ads.
    • Rankings See how players stack up in each state.
    • Player Profiles Build your own profile and join the Prep Redzone database.
    • Coach Views Get notified when a college coach views your profile.
    • Profile Trends Track your Player Profile views over time.
    • Recruiting Tasks Stay on-track in the recruiting process
    • Recruiting Dashboard All your recruiting tools in a single place.
    • College Match Recommends colleges that match with your profile.
    • Coach Contacts Contact any program in the country.
    • Event Credits Save $25 on all Prep Redzone combines.
    • Recruiting Tips Become an expert on the recruiting process.
    • College Email Templates Send customized emails directly to college coaches.
    • How We Rank
  • New York
  • Rankings
    • How We Rank

    • Archived Rankings

    • 2026 Rankings

    • 2027 Rankings

    • 2028 Watch List

  • Player Database
  • 2025 Team Previews
  • Scouts
  • Home
  • Coverage
      Choose Your State Middle School Coverage
      Alabama
      Arizona
      Arkansas
      California
      Canada
      Colorado
      Dakotas
      Florida
      Georgia
      Idaho
      Illinois
      Indiana
      Iowa
      Kansas
      Kentucky
      Louisiana
      Maryland
      Michigan
      Minnesota
      Mississippi
      Missouri
      Nebraska
      Nevada
      New England
      New Jersey
      New Mexico
      New York
      North Carolina
      Ohio
      Oklahoma
      Oregon
      Pennsylvania
      South Carolina
      Tennessee
      Texas
      Utah
      Virginia
      Washington
      West Virginia
      Wisconsin
  • Events
      Tournaments
      • 7 on 7 7 on 7
      Showcases
      • Combine Series Combine Series
      About Our Events
  • Rankings
      Loading...
  • Features
      Prep Redzone for
      • Players
      • Parents
      • Club Coaches
      • High School Coaches
      • College Coaches
      • Fans
      View All Features
      • Coverage Access Prep Redzone articles year-round without ads.
      • Rankings See how players stack up in each state.
      • Player Profiles Build your own profile and join the Prep Redzone database.
      • Coach Views Get notified when a college coach views your profile.
      • Profile Trends Track your Player Profile views over time.
      • Recruiting Tasks Stay on-track in the recruiting process
      • Recruiting Dashboard All your recruiting tools in a single place.
      • College Match Recommends colleges that match with your profile.
      • Coach Contacts Contact any program in the country.
      • Event Credits Save $25 on all Prep Redzone combines.
      • Recruiting Tips Become an expert on the recruiting process.
      • College Email Templates Send customized emails directly to college coaches.
  • About Us
      • How We Rank
  • Support
Login Subscribe

2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked

2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Caleb Holfoth
Caleb Holfoth
May 20, 2023 @ 10:00 AM
Facebook
X (Formerly Twitter)

In this article:

Tavion Byrd
Tavion Byrd 6'1" | 175 lbs | QB | 2025
NY
Donovan O’Toole
Donovan O’Toole 5'8" | 148 lbs | WR | 2025
NY
Malachi McCaskill
Malachi McCaskill 5'11" | 180 lbs | RB | 2025
NY
Levi Altshuler
Levi Altshuler 6'0" | 190 lbs | QB | 2026
New E
Michael Dietrich
Michael Dietrich 6'0" | 185 lbs | WR | 2025
NY
Terron Johnson
Terron Johnson 5'11" | 170 lbs | DB | 2026
New E
Matt Davitt
Matt Davitt 6'0" | 185 lbs | DB | 2025
NY
Brayden Smith
Brayden Smith 6'2" | 175 lbs | QB | 2025
NY
Geoffrey Galloway
Geoffrey Galloway 5'11" | 175 lbs | DB | 2025
NY
<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>It is not easy to rank JV players due to the upcoming change in competition level, but all these guys have clear traits that are recruitable and could end up at the next level. Most of these kids form the CHSFL JV league due to the fact that it is the most competitive JV league in New York. Because the transition to varsity is not easy to project, and the outcomes can lead to inconsistent results, some of these guys could jump way high up the rankings with strong seasons. Either way, their JV careers are in the past and are names you should watch this fall. </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:acf/evaluation-block {"name":"acf/evaluation-block","data":{"player_evaluations_0_player":["735861"],"_player_evaluations_0_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_0_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_0_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_0_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_0_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_0_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='735861' first='Malachi' last='McCaskill'] was kept on JV because of a huge 2023 graduating class and there is a really chance he becomes a solid prospect in the CHSFL this fall. McCaskill definitely is undersized but has legitimate elite speed. McCaskill is a smooth runner who finds running lanes well and does a good job of making quick cuts upfield to maximize yards gained. A really solid prospect, with all these transitions up a level it is hard to project players ability but McCaskill is a name to watch.","_player_evaluations_0_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_1_player":["805581"],"_player_evaluations_1_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_1_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_1_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_1_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_1_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_1_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='805581' first='Tavion' last='Byrd'] is a really promising young quarterback prospect out of Rochester and has some really solid recruitable measurables. Byrd is long and lean and has some really impressive arm talent. Byrd will be the engine of a UPrep offense that has a ton of playmakers. Byrd is in for a big season and could be a name that blows up this fall not just because of his measurables and skillset but the potential to be the most potent offense in Rochester with several talented playmakers by his side.","_player_evaluations_1_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_2_player":["514952"],"_player_evaluations_2_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_2_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_2_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_2_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_2_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_2_evaluation":"In terms of production, there were not many who matched [player_tooltip player_id='514952' first='Michael' last='Dietrich'] for Chaminade. Dietrich has had a strong offseason with a strong showing at the Elite V showcase and the WR could easily become Chaminde's top target. Dietrich is a smooth athlete with good measurables and all signs indicated that he will have one of the smoother transitions to Varsity out of players from this list. Just as the case with McCaskill a strong 2023 from Chaminade was a roadblock for earlier varsity reps.","_player_evaluations_2_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_3_player":["528737"],"_player_evaluations_3_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_3_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_3_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_3_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_3_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_3_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='528737' first='Levi' last='Altshuler'] was one of the most impressive JV quarterbacks in New York last season. The Iona Prep signal caller will likely find himself in a QB competition this fall but with really good arm talent and some really advanced poise and patience in the pocket Altshuler is some really quality traits. Altshuler does a good job of working in rhythm and is a really quality pocket passer. As an athlete Altshuler is not a huge threat with his legs but does have the athleticism to move in the pocket and adjust making throws on the run.","_player_evaluations_3_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_4_player":["452167"],"_player_evaluations_4_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_4_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_4_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_4_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_4_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_4_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='452167' first='Matt' last='Davitt'] has elite speed and one of the most transferable traits to a higher level is speed. Davitt will be amongst a strong WR group at Iona Prep and opportunities may be limited but there is clear potential here. Davitt has the speed and is a good route runner and really solid production wise. A prospect to watch who is also an elite performer in track and field.","_player_evaluations_4_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_5_player":["735863"],"_player_evaluations_5_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_5_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_5_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_5_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_5_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_5_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='735863' first='Donovan' last='O'Toole'] could be the most interesting prospect here due to how limited he is due to size but there is not a player with more elite quickness and twitch than O'Toole. A really quality route runner O'Toole can mov quicker than most if not all the DBs in the CHSFL. The size will be a concern but there is a very unique niche potential for O'Toole and he is a guy to keep an eye on.","_player_evaluations_5_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_6_player":["243060"],"_player_evaluations_6_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_6_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_6_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_6_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_6_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_6_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='243060' first='Geoffrey' last='Galloway'] steps onto varsity with an Iona Prep team that returns several quality defensive backs. Galloway is a really strong in coverage and does a good job of mirroring receivers. Galloway is a name to watch this fall and could eventually grow into the role of DB across from [player_tooltip player_id='505380' first='Terron' last='Johnson'] and continue Iona Prep fielding really strong cornerback duos.","_player_evaluations_6_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations_7_player":["278647"],"_player_evaluations_7_player":"field_62ab9d62ecf2c","player_evaluations_7_override_profile_image":"","_player_evaluations_7_override_profile_image":"override-player-profile-image","player_evaluations_7_not_in_database":"","_player_evaluations_7_not_in_database":"field_62aba48cecf2d","player_evaluations_7_evaluation":"[player_tooltip player_id='278647' first='Brayden' last='Smith']'s path to a starting role is blocked by Matt Porter, but Smith has good size and arm talent and will get some quality varsity reps. Smith, like Porter will have to put it all on the field his Senior year and there will be eyes watching as CBA-Syracuse has a strong 2025 class and Smith will be able to perform alongside. Quality traits and a name to know as the season goes on.","_player_evaluations_7_evaluation":"field_62aba51aecf34","player_evaluations":8,"_player_evaluations":"field_62aba7547dc44"},"mode":"edit","alignText":"left","fullHeight":false,"anchor":"acf-block-6456bf83032c2"} /-->

It is not easy to rank JV players due to the upcoming change in competition level, but all these guys have clear traits that are recruitable and could end up at the next level. Most of these kids form the CHSFL JV league due to the fact that it is the most competitive JV league in New York. Because the transition to varsity is not easy to project, and the outcomes can lead to inconsistent results, some of these guys could jump way high up the rankings with strong seasons. Either way, their JV careers are in the past and are names you should watch this fall.

Malachi McCaskill

Malachi McCaskill

NY
RB
HEIGHT 5'11"
WEIGHT 180
POS RB
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Malachi
McCaskill RB
Class
2025
Height
5'11"
Weight
180
HS
Kellenberg
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Malachi McCaskill was kept on JV because of a huge 2023 graduating class and there is a really...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Malachi McCaskill

Twitter
State: New York
School: Kellenberg
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation
Stony Brook
Tavion Byrd

Tavion Byrd

NY
QB
HEIGHT 6'1"
WEIGHT 175
POS QB
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Tavion
Byrd QB
Class
2025
Height
6'1"
Weight
175
HS
University Prep
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Tavion Byrd is a really promising young quarterback prospect out of Rochester and has some really solid recruitable...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Stony Brook
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Tavion Byrd

Twitter
State: New York
School: University Prep
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

Tufts
Michael Dietrich

Michael Dietrich

NY
WR
HEIGHT 6'0"
WEIGHT 185
POS WR
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Michael
Dietrich WR
Class
2025
Height
6'0"
Weight
185
HS
Chaminade
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
In terms of production, there were not many who matched Michael Dietrich for Chaminade. Dietrich has had a...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Tufts
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Michael Dietrich

Instagram Twitter
State: New York
School: Chaminade
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

Levi Altshuler

Levi Altshuler

New E
QB
HEIGHT 6'0"
WEIGHT 190
POS QB
CLASS 2026
View Player
​
Levi
Altshuler QB
Class
2026
Height
6'0"
Weight
190
HS
Berkshire School
|
New E
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Levi Altshuler was one of the most impressive JV quarterbacks in New York last season. The Iona Prep...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Levi Altshuler

State: New England
School: Berkshire School
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

Fordham
Matt Davitt

Matt Davitt

NY
DB
HEIGHT 6'0"
WEIGHT 185
POS DB
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Matt
Davitt DB
Class
2025
Height
6'0"
Weight
185
HS
Iona Prep
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Matt Davitt has elite speed and one of the most transferable traits to a higher level is speed....
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Fordham
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Matt Davitt

Twitter
State: New York
School: Iona Prep
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

Palm Beach Atlantic
Donovan O’Toole

Donovan O’Toole

NY
WR
HEIGHT 5'8"
WEIGHT 148
POS WR
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Donovan
O’Toole WR
Class
2025
Height
5'8"
Weight
148
HS
Kellenberg Memorial
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Donovan O’Toole could be the most interesting prospect here due to how limited he is due to size...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Palm Beach Atlantic
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Donovan O’Toole

Instagram Twitter
State: New York
School: Kellenberg Memorial
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

Geoffrey Galloway

Geoffrey Galloway

NY
DB
HEIGHT 5'11"
WEIGHT 175
POS DB
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Geoffrey
Galloway DB
Class
2025
Height
5'11"
Weight
175
HS
Iona Prep
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Geoffrey Galloway steps onto varsity with an Iona Prep team that returns several quality defensive backs. Galloway is...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Geoffrey Galloway

Instagram Twitter
State: New York
School: Iona Prep
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

St. John Fisher
Brayden Smith

Brayden Smith

NY
QB
HEIGHT 6'2"
WEIGHT 175
POS QB
CLASS 2025
View Player
​
Brayden
Smith QB
Class
2025
Height
6'2"
Weight
175
HS
CBA-Syracuse
|
NY
2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked
Brayden Smith ‘s path to a starting role is blocked by Matt Porter, but Smith has good size...
Written by Caleb Holfoth
St. John Fisher
Read more at PrepRedzone.com
Prep Redzone

Brayden Smith

Instagram Twitter
State: New York
School: CBA-Syracuse
Subscribe below to view this player's evaluation

Highlights

Prep Redzone

Access all of Prep Redzone

Continue reading this article and more.

Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Log in

Rankings

717 Players Ranked

  • 1
    Messiah Hampton

    Messiah Hampton

    James Monroe

    Oregon
  • 2
    Jacob Butler

    Jacob Butler

    Long Island Lutheran

    Stanford
  • 3
    Crew Davis

    Crew Davis

    Iona Prep

    UNC-Chapel Hill
    Lacrosse & Football
  • 4
    Ameir Morrow

    Ameir Morrow

    Erasmus Hall

  • 5
    Daniel White

    Daniel White

    Half Hollow Hills East

View Full Rankings

Related Articles

  • Western New England And Cortland Extend Offers To NY Prospects

    Western New England And Cortland Extend Offers To NY Prospects

    Cory Lemer • August 10

  • St. John Fisher Offers NY Prospects

    St. John Fisher Offers NY Prospects

    Cory Lemer • August 9

  • PRNY Season Preview Star Players to Watch

    PRNY Season Preview Star Players to Watch

    Matt Di Domenico • August 8

  • PSR Big Camp Series, New Jersey: Offensive Linemen, Volume IV

    PSR Big Camp Series, New Jersey: Offensive Linemen, Volume IV

    Brendan Mankarious • August 8

  • August Rankings Update: Who moved up the rankings in New York’s 2026 class?

    August Rankings Update: Who moved up the rankings in New York’s 2026 class?

    Prep Redzone Staff • August 7

Follow Us

  • Michael Keighron

    Michael Keighron

    @CoachKeighron

  • Matt Di Domenico

    Matt Di Domenico

    @didomenicomatt5

Loading...
Home New York 2025 Rankings: JV -> Ranked

Prep Network

  • Prep Dig
  • Prep Girls Hoops
  • Prep Hoops
  • Prep Lacrosse
  • Prep Redzone
  • Prep Soccer
  • Prep Softball

Company

  • News
  • Careers
  • Store
  • Partner Interest Form

Resources

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Cookie Policy
  • Recruiting Tips
  • Student Loan Resources
  • College Scholarship Search

Support

  • My Account
  • Contact
  • Sitemap

© 2025 Prep Redzone. All rights reserved.