Peyton Robinson
Peyton Robinson
About Peyton
Badges
Riser
Expert Analysis
Cory Lemer | Prep Redzone Scout
Standing at 6’1″ 180-pounds, Robinson has an average build for the QB position. Coming off a breakout Junior season where he compiled over 2,600 yards and 32 touchdowns.
In his film, Robinson makes his case for the states top QB. He has a pretty deep ball which is delivered with solid accuracy. He stays calm and collected in the pocket and can hit throws across the field with accuracy. He can use his legs and become a dual-threat prospect, but his first reaction is to throw, using his outstanding IQ to read a defense.
Robinson is a steady riser in the Prep Redzone rankings for a good reason. On tape he is easily a top QB in the state. He has a lot of hype around him making him a must watch as we enter the fall.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationJared Valluzzi | Prep Redzone Scout
Coming off a breakout junior year with Long Island Lutheran, Robinson had plenty of buzz heading into the event—and he delivered. In the morning session, he made a strong case as the top quarterback at the showcase. Calm and composed, Robinson displayed a smooth delivery and threw an accurate deep ball. With plenty of reps to work with, he took full advantage of the opportunity, consistently making plays and standing out among the group.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationCaleb Holfoth | Prep Redzone Scout
Robinson was good on Saturday during pool play, doing what he needed for 3rd & Ten to compete in every game, but on Sunday, he was on a different level. His 0 Interceptions and dominant performances in several elimination games against the top teams at the tournament showed us a lot.
Robinson did an excellent job of using everyone on the field; his ability to get through reads and deliver with the right timing was something few QBs showed capability of throughout Sunday.
It was great to see Robinson throw for the first time in this setting because on tape, you see a ton of deep throws, so I never really had questions about his arm strength. However, with 40-yard fields in 7v7, Robinson was excellent at targeting all short and intermediate areas of the field and doing so with consistent ball placement.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationCaleb Holfoth | Prep Redzone Scout
Robinson took advantage of his transfer and first year as a full-time starter at Long Island Lutheran; he got some run at St. Anthony’s last season and put some good stuff on tape, but a full season of tape as the starter gives coaches a ton to evaluate.
Arm Talent: Not many quarterbacks push the ball down the field as consistently as Robinson does; while it is a great display of his arm talent down the field, he is able to attack the deep third of coverage so often that you almost look for more short-area throws on tape. He can attack the middle of the field, the sideline, and anything 30+ yards down the field. Robinson has a few reps of it on tape.
Deep Accuracy: He has the arm to get it there, but actually, connecting on those throws is not easy. Multiple reps show great ball placement along the sidelines, where throws can only be caught by WRs, and there are also plenty of reps getting the ball between closing safeties. The ability to push the ball down the field accurately is what lands Robinson near the top of this quarterback class.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationCaleb Holfoth | Prep Redzone Scout
Robinson was not a full-time starter last season for St. Anthony’s and played early in the season until 2025 ATH/QB
Gary Merrill
Gary
Merrill
6'1" | 180 lbs | ATH
St. Anthony's | 2025
State
NY
broke out with his strong season. Robinson got a good run against Cardinal Hayes and Delbarton, and the sophomore signal caller looked really solid in both outings. Robinson may not have a ton of tape, but he showed some intriguing reps on film against high-quality opponents.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationJared Valluzzi | Prep Redzone Scout
The 2026 quarterback out of St Anthony’s has a bright future for the Friars and if they definitely elect to move him up to varsity as a sophomore, we’ll have a QB battle on our hands. Robinson has a fantastic arm and he’s a great athlete. The upside is enormous for him and he made smart throws during these 7v7’s being able to zip the ball to his receivers in the right spot. He’s still a very young quarterback and will need to put on weight to be ready for the size and physicality of the NYCHSFL AAA division, but his potential is something to track for the next three years.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationPlayer Claimed
