2025 NY Rankings: Defensive Line
In this article:
This defensive line group features three prospects in the top 9 prospects - more than any other position group in the top group. It is led by a couple of prospects who are highly sought-after P4 offensive linemen and followed by a really deep group of Division 1 prospects. This year there are even several really high-level D2/D3 prospects and a class that could easily see 30+ players play college football. There are guys all around the state and it is led by the NYCHSFL which features 4 of the top 5 defensive linemen which comes as no surprise as year over year they continue to produce the best big man talent in the state.
Not much intro needed for this group but here is some analysis on the top ' 25DL in the state.
Check out updated NY 2025 Rankings Here
#1 Overall
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Blake? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
The Next 9
Kadear Dembele
Kadear
Dembele
6'3" | 295 lbs | DL
West Haven | 2025
State
New E
- Dembele burst onto the scene in his first season with Stepinac and a couple of CHSFL coaches mentioned to me that he was one of the toughest players to gameplan for. A wrecking ball at 6'3 295lbs Dembele showcases the athleticism to line up anywhere from 0-tech right over the center to standing up as a wide-9 or OLB-like alignment coming off the edge. Not many players can play inside out like that and he had the natural power to make plays from anywhere.
Quante Gillians
Quante
Gillians
6'4" | 250 lbs | DL
Aquinas | 2025
State
NY
- Gillians is probably the most natural defensive end on the list so far and he has really good bend and length coming off the edge. He is really sought after by a couple of major P4 programs and can play a couple of different positions in different defenses at the next level. He moves well enough to be an outside linebacker but has the frame to continue growing into his body and playing at 250+ at defensive end. He has some offensive tape at tight end which really showcases his burst and ability to change direction.
Gabriel George
Gabriel
George
6'5" | 250 lbs | DL
Iona Prep | 2025
State
NY
- George who had one of the most impressive show days for Iona Prep picked up multiple offers and all it takes is his measurables and body type to understand why. There are not many players built like George playing in New York and at the next level as he continues to add strength and mass to his frame he has the potential to become a very strong/long big defensive end or slide into a 3-tech role. George a PrepRedzone camp alum had a very impressive first season in the CHSFL.
Kahmari Valentine
Kahmari
Valentine
5'11" | 320 lbs | DL
Cardinal Hayes | 2025
State
NY
- Valentine has some of the quickest hands in this class and his upfield burst with a strong violent initial punch on offensive lineman standout on tape. At 320lbs Valentine moves better than a lot of guys in this class and playing with the type of motor he does he naturally finds himself around the ball. Valentine is a player who gets overlooked because of his height but he is proven against the best offensive lineman in New York. There may not be a player who has a stronger impact on a game-to-game basis then Valentine and his ability to get around blocks on the interior.
Mason Alnutt
Mason
Alnutt
6'4" | 250 lbs | DL
Canisius | 2025
State
NY
- Alnutt, the best DL out of WNY this season has a good frame at 6'3 250 and has some quality numbers in the weight room. The transformation of his body over the past two seasons has been huge getting much stronger and bigger and there is still a lot of room for him to grow. Alnutt has quick feet and coming off the edge has the natural power in his upper body to be an effective bull rusher.
Marques Garrett
Marques
Garrett
6'3" | 240 lbs | EDGE
Fairport | 2025
State
NY
- Garrett who shows a lot of quality movement skills on the offensive side of the ball at tight end could potentially be a bigger outside LB prospect but has the length and strength to play off the edge. Garrett's length coming off the edge helps him close on quarterbacks outside the pocket and he shows good overall finishing ability around the LOS. He is physical with his hands at the point of attack does a really good job of making plays on power runs where he takes on a lead blocker who is usually pulling.
Tyler Davis
Tyler
Davis
6'4" | 225 lbs | EDGE
Erasmus Hall | 2025
State
NY
- Davis will have big shoes to fill this upcoming season with Erasmus Hall losing some quality DL to college but he has the length, motor, and violent hands that make him an intriguing DE prospect. Davis is the lightest prospect on this list at 225 but he can play at 240 plus and showcases good burst and explosive movements for a player his size.
Cole Sisson
Cole
Sisson
6'4" | 260 lbs | DL
Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake | 2025
State
NY
- Sisson is very big and strong and the interior DL out of Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake is one of the best block shedders in the state. His hands are physical and violent and he does a good job of staying active trying to get off blocks. Sisson plays with a high motor and is consistent in his ability to finish plays both around the LOS and in the open field.
Marquan Saddler Jr
Marquan
Saddler Jr
6'1" | 280 lbs | DL
CBA-Syracuse | 2025
State
NY
- Saddler Jr is another big interior DL prospect whose best position could be at 1-tech, when you watch some of his clips playing Lacrosse you see really impressive athleticism and movement skills. Saddler is long for being 6'1 and quick off the ball. While he does show some positional versatility moving around the D-line for CBA-Syracuse his best play comes from the inside where his quickness is a lot for bigger interior OL to handle.
Five Players To Watch This Upcoming Season
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Lewis? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Edward? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Jah’rece? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Tyler? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Moses? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to see the full player ranking.
View RankingsAccess all of Prep Redzone
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.