Scott Carmichael
Scott Carmichael
About Scott
Expert Analysis
Amal Scott | Prep Redzone Scout
Carmichael has transformed from a promising underclassman into a dominant force on the line, drawing attention from Division I programs. His year-over-year development that truly sets him apart. Last year, he showed raw size and athleticism, but there were areas for refinement—footwork that occasionally lagged in pass sets, hands that needed more precision, and a finishing mentality that was developing. Fast forward to this season, and Carmichael looks like a completely retooled prospect, more explosive, technically sound, and aggressive. Carmichael’s footwork has seen a dramatic upgrade. Previously, his feet were serviceable but lacked the quickness to consistently mirror speedy edge rushers or climb effectively in run schemes. This year, his feet are much improved—lighter, more balanced, and reactive. This ties directly into his faster first step off the snap, which has shaved precious tenths of a second off his initial burst. Whether it’s firing out in a zone scheme or pulling on counters, that enhanced get-off allows him to engage defenders before they can dictate the point of attack. Another standout area is his ability to get to the second level quickly. In prior footage, Carmichael would occasionally get bogged down at the line, struggling to disengage and advance. Now, he’s exploding through contact and reaching linebackers with authority, creating lanes for Andover’s backs to exploit. This improvement speaks to better conditioning and pad level, as he’s maintaining leverage while ascending.
Hand usage has been a game-changer for Carmichael. His improved hands are now active and violent, placing inside defenders’ frames with consistency. He’s mastered the push-pull technique to disrupt and redirect opponents, often yanking them off-balance or steering them wide. This wasn’t as refined last year, where he relied more on sheer size; now, it’s a weapon that creates mismatches. Combined with his overall more aggressive demeanor, Carmichael plays with a mean streak that’s infectious. He’s not just occupying space—he’s dominating reps. Perhaps most impressive is his commitment to finishing blocks. Gone are the days of partial engagement; Carmichael now looks to drive defenders to the sideline or pancake them to the ground. This finisher’s mentality shows up in every clip, turning good blocks into great ones and demoralizing opposing fronts. It’s the kind of intangible that fans love and coaches covet, as it elevates the entire offense’s physicality.
Access all of Prep Redzone
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationPlayer Claimed
